Makerspaces Failure & Success: The Only Way to Learn

For the last two years our district has been integrating the #makerspace movement into our libraries.  I love it!  Here is a quick blog post about some of my successes and failures throughout the journey.

Makerspace Logistics

  • Audience: Grades K-5
  • Structure: During checkout, half of the students checkout while the other half do makerspaces, then they swap places.  Some teachers come for 20 minutes, others come for 30 minutes.  Some teachers don’t do them at all.  I am hoping to change that by getting feedback from teachers after this year.
  • Management:  I have suggested that teachers split boy/girl so that they can tell who is at makerspaces and who is checking out more easily.  A few kids like to double dip on their makerspace time.  Our library is full of energy and…noise.  Our makerspaces are independent work spaces where students can learn, create, share, and have fun.

Failure & Success

#1: Lanyards, vests, anything kids have to wear to identify them at a makerspace, makes for a lot of work on the librarian’s side of things.  The best solution I have found for this is a whiteboard with the different makerspaces listed and how many spots are at each makerspace in Sharpie marker.  Students write their names or class numbers next to the makerspace spot they are at and head on their way.  I do have to rewrite this because Expo over Sharpie=erasing, but it is much easier than making and laminating tags for lanyards!

#2: Take-Apart Technology stations should really be monitored.  Real tools in the hands of first graders without direct supervision can get a little dicey.  It was worth a try and the kids loved it, but next time it will be a club where I can directly monitor the students!

#3: Some of the best makerspaces are FREE!!!  My students LOVE the paper airplane makerspace.  To control flight patterns, I place a target on the window in hopes they will aim for that.  Service centered makerspaces, such as holiday cards for the homeless, is always a highlight.

#4: All children, K-5 love puppets.  It sounds silly and I think our intermediate grade teachers secretly hate the puppets, but I love that 5th graders get into it.  Sure they are being silly and laughing, but childhood flies by too fast.  I say let the kids play!  Puppets and legos are the only two makerspaces that stick around all year.  The other 3-4 change about every 2 months.

#5: I typically have a vision for how I want a makerspace to go, but the students find their own vision.  Something I have learned is to LET GO!  Sure, they may not be building the exact replica of the GoldieBlox design, but they are probably making something pretty cool!

#6: TAPE. Kids love tape.  Beware of the tape.

#7: Video taping how the makerspaces work is helpful for teachers and students. I have posted the videos on the library facebook page for parents as well.  I started out strong this year, but then…school happened. My goal is to get back to this in August.

#8: Some things that didn’t go as smoothly as I had hoped as independent spaces for students. Makey Makey, Spheros, Little Bits, and green screen (Do Ink App).  These need a little more guidance next year and may be clubs with solid introductions or classroom lessons prior to incorporating them into makerspaces.

#9: One of my favorite makerspaces is the Imagination Playground.  Our PTO bought this for the school and it is AMAZING.  I love the collaboration it creates and creativity it fosters.  We have the large blocks.  I’d really love my own set.  Hint, hint.

#10: Signage.  This is my weak area.  I am not a crafty design person and students love to manipulate (erase, rewrite, move) signage that isn’t permanent. I have tried plastic stands, which work pretty well, but they often get overlooked. I don’t see this as a huge issue, but it is something I strive to improve.

Have any questions or feedback?  Feel free to hit me up on Twitter @mediaspecjess or email me at


For the Love of Poetry

I love poetry month!  I offered poetry lessons for our kindergarten through fifth grade classes and met with 21/27 of them.  I shared a google spreadsheet with our staff and asked them to sign up if they wanted a lesson.  Of course, the first link I sent out didn’t work, but eventually the ball got rolling.  I also posted the lesson idea on my March 2015 Daily Flush aka the toilet stall newsletter.

I love my job because I easily get bored and crave challenges in my profession.  Hence, the reason I have never taught the same grade level consecutively, nor save my plan books each year.  Yuck.  I love to recreate, stretch and grow and being a library media specialist suits me well because I get to do this daily.

In planning my lessons the first step was about promoting it.  I provided students with a poetry challenge, talked about it on our morning announcements, and like I said previously, I stalked the teachers. 🙂  Next came the planning.  My first step is looking at the vertical articulation for ELA standards to make sure I am on track and then to consider additional standards if those don’t seem meaty enough.  Here are the learning targets I created for each grade level.  The learning targets did improve as my lessons went on.

Next, I consider my toughest grade level first, 5th grade.  I swear, I can’t get these kids excited about ANYTHING!  So, I turned to pop culture in hopes to hook them into the amazing world of poetry and figurative language.  The first lesson I taught, I used some songs and lyrics that I eventually realized could have been controversial, so I finally landed on Ferrel Williams, Happy and Flo Rida, Good Feeling.

As the students walked in I had the music blaring in the library.  No, our library is never quiet.  I could see it on their faces…I had them.  I would let them jam out for a bit and then get our learn on.  I am a freak about the importance of learning targets and refer to them often through out the lesson to ensure the students know their task and their goals.  My first question to the students was, Who loves music? All hands flew up.  Who loves poetry? All hands went down. I cried a little, but it was a trick.  I then told them that their love of music is actually a love for poetry, they just didn’t know it yet and yes, I do know they are not technically the same thing and would go on to explain that, but I wanted the students to see the parallel to figurative language in their lives.  I also would weave in where poetry is in the library and a review of the word genre.

I then would move to our learning targets and for fifth grade they were: We can examine how words and phrases create a deeper meaning in literature with similes, metaphors, hyperboles, and imagery.  We can explain the deeper meaning of the figurative language (this learning target was an upgrade after a couple of lessons).  We can create figurative language.  I had the students read the targets with me to begin so we were all on the same page.  We defined similes, metaphors, hyperboles, and imagery and wrote examples on the board.  We reread the learning targets and I told them their mission was to identify any figurative language, but not to worry, we would do this together too.  I then would pass out the lyrics and a high lighter and turn the music up. Everyone would sing and I would remind them of their learning target and let them continue on their way.  We worked through the first set of lyrics together, share our ideas, then dive back into the lyrics to find more figurative language.  I would challenge the students who thought this was easy, to start to label the figurative language and explain their thinking in the margins.  After we examined the lyrics and discussed our ideas, it was the students’ turn to create.  I turned it over to them to write something with figurative language and gathered their information to provide data for their teacher.  I didn’t think to do this originally, so the first 5th grade teacher didn’t get this. Sorry!

I taught grades 2-5 using this same strategy, but tweaking the targets to fit their grade level needs.  I was able to use the lyrics for our second graders because of the repeating lines and rhyming.  In kindergarten and first grade their standards were so different that I had them look at poetry that met their standards.  In kindergarten the lesson was modeled as a whole group, but in first grade students were able to highlight and identify words about their senses and feelings in the poems.  The toughest grade to get going was typically 3rd grade and it makes sense because it is the first time the standards actually define the different types of figurative language.  In the third grade lessons we didn’t have time to create because we spent more time talking to build their understanding.  There was definitely a rise and fall to my stamina as I did this 21 times, but it was a blast and our poetry section has never been so empty!

IMAG1604IMAG1603 IMAG1644IMAG1605

Responsible Researchers

For a long time now I have promoted the use of Google search for students of any age. Why? Because it isn’t going anywhere and instead of fearing the things that students can find, we need to teach them how to use the search engine responsibly.  What a great teaching moment for something possibly inappropriate to appear in a Google search and for a child to have YOU standing there to support that finding and what to do next.  Students are going to use Google to search for information, so don’t we want to model, facilitate, and instruct with it wisely?

I have been working with a couple of 5th grade classrooms on finding reliable resources.  Here are our tricks and tips.

Reliable Resources: Things to Check

URL: org, gov, edu

Is it from a Reputable Institution? (museum, news media, expert, reputable organization)

Check 3 sites to confirm finding

Check the date of publication (bottom or top of site)

Check bibliography- Are sources cited?

Check author-Google search to see who they are

I talk about the things to check when researching online and model how to find them via Apple TV and then the students log into their GoogleDrive accounts.  Once we are there we go to the research tool and talk about filtering our search.  Then the students start to search for 3 resources and use the citation tool to cite student sources.  When they are done they share their document with me and I post this rubric on it (see below).  I will be updating the rubric based on a reflection I had while planning this same set of lessons with another class. Instead of writing a paragraph, the students in this class are going to target a specific audience and create ways to teach the information they are learning to others.

Screen Shot 2014-11-17 at 3.24.11 PM

After students read and write down key information I have been showing them this YouTube video about mind mapping and how it helps our brain synthesize information. The thing I love about mind mapping is that it provides an opportunity for multiple modes of thinking to be seen on paper.  Below you will see some example mind maps that our students created.

 Screen Shot 2014-11-19 at 2.04.02 PM
Screen Shot 2014-11-19 at 2.13.55 PM

 After talking with the classroom teacher we decided his class would create books or presentations for their second grade buddies.  It works out perfectly that second grade has standards that also align with 5th grade.  I love it when a plan comes together!!  This is the synthesizing presentation I used with the students.


Some Rules Need Revisions

I began writing this Oct. 3, but now that I am on fall break I have time to finish it! 🙂 As always, thank you for reading!

I. Am. Exhausted. Last night our school held parent/teacher conferences and I thought it would be the perfect timing to see my passion project turn into a reality.

Back story:

Our district libraries have been planning to purchase and circulate eBooks for a couple of years. Our middle and high schools rolled it out before the elementaries just to see how it would go. It has been amazing to get resources from them and to hear about their experiences to help us.

With this roll out of eBooks, one thing that keeps me awake at night is the thought that not all students have the same opportunities at home. I wanted to think of a way to get books into hands and devices into homes that may not have access to them. This launched me on a crusade to figure out how we could use our district library funds to purchase eReaders. I asked around the district and was told that our budget categories and definitions didn’t allow for spending money on eReaders.  See the response I got below.

“The audio visual account expenditures is defined by the State Board of Accounts.  The definition of what can be purchased with these monies is”  Audiovisual:  Activities concerned with selecting, preparing, storing, and maintaining audiovisual equipment, films, filmstrips, transparencies, tapes, and TV programs as well as associated services.  I know what you’re thinking…. This definition is outdate, and I agree with you.”

As much as I wanted to be okay with this answer, I just couldn’t let it go. I couldn’t sleep. How could we possibly be servicing 21st century learners with such an archaic definition?  How could I possibly “grow” my students if I couldn’t provide them with current technology for reading?  So… I called the State Board of Accounts and spoke to a kind man who agreed that the definition was a bit outdated and that it would be okay to purchase eReaders with our library accounts.  He gave me his contact information and said he would be glad to talk with our district leaders. Long story short, the district did agree to use funds to purchase eReaders, but we established a hardware budget line to get it done. Woohoo!  The day I heard the news, I was ecstatic! I was on my way!

My next major challenge was considering how to circulate the eReaders to make a difference for our students who don’t have devices at home. How could I find out who didn’t have a device? A survey? A guess? Nothing seemed like it would work well and I was stuck for a while.  Then it dawned on me that I needed a chance to help ALL parents and I knew they would be in the school for parent/teacher conferences, so I wouldn’t have to lure them in just for ebooks.  It was perfect.  I posted an announcement on my library Facebook page and asked teachers to send information via email and hoped for the best.

Screen Shot 2014-10-13 at 10.58.42 AM

With much thanks to Melissa Brisco, our previous Director of Learning and Terry Rich our Executive Director of Business, for considering this change and helping it become a reality. As well as a huge thanks to Ben Walters our Network Manager for making it possible to open up our wireless during parent/teacher conferences so that I could run a help desk for parents who have devices and to provide eReaders for parents that did not.

Over the course of two days, with the help of Travis Penn, District Technology Supervisor, Jenny Sebbas, Technology Assistant HelpDesk Manager, and Lauren Smith our Instructional Coach at Noble Crossing, we were able to help 126 families access eBooks through their own devices and circulate the 10 Kindle Fires to homes that do not have tablets or wireless.

The smiles on faces of parents and students has made it worth the hard work and risk taking to question a rule that needed revision.  Thank you to all that have helped make my passion project a reality. Anything is possible when people work together!

“Never doubt that a small group of thoughtful, committed, citizens can change the world. Indeed, it is the only thing that ever has.”
― Margaret Mead





“Keep creating!”

I received information from @caharvey2 that Baker and Taylor was supporting a coloring contest based on the book The Day the Crayons Quit written by Drew Daywalt and illustrated by Oliver Jeffers.  I love this book and the different personalities of the crayons.  I decided to run with the idea of creativity and emailed our staff to see if anyone would be interested in a lesson on creativity for their students.  As always, the staff here jumped right on board and I have scheduled out several lessons in the next two weeks.

First, I prompted the students to take time to think about what the word creativity meant to them. Students paired and shared their thoughts, and then we came together as a whole group to share.  We listed key ideas on the whiteboard.  Next, I pulled up this video from Kid President (I LOVE HIM!!) and paused at different places to think, pair, and share about his ideas, who he consulted, and what he realized at the end of his catcuum experience.  Our big takeaway was that ideas don’t always work out the way we want them to, but we “Gotta keep creating!”

After the video I read The Day the Crayons Quit and we focused on the author and illustrators creativity with personification, illustrations, and humor. The students then had time to create pictures like Duncan does in the story to help the crayons all feel a little bit better.  The students did a gallery walk to observe student creations and then we voted on the top three by placing sticky notes on our favorite creative picture.

We ended the lesson by talking about how some people had more sticky notes than others, but just like Kid President, we “Gotta keep on creating!”  Below you will see the top three choices in this particular class.  I have 7 more lessons to do just like this one, although I am sure I will change things along the way because… I gotta keep creating!

Screen Shot 2014-08-12 at 3.43.08 PM

Contest information: DayCrayonsBT